image001

THE FUND

 

The Fund

 

The Regulations require the Committee to maintain a fund to provide for the payment of current and prospective benefits to members of the scheme. In order to ensure that this objective is achieved, the Committee must determine a suitable investment strategy, which provides both a high return on investments and an acceptable level of risk.

 

All income received by the Committee, including employees’ and employers’ contributions, rents, interest and dividends are paid into the Fund. Expenditure, such as monthly pensions, retirement allowances, death grants, refunds and the administration costs of the Committee are met from the Fund.

 

The assets and liabilities of the Fund are valued every three years by the Scheme actuary. Following each valuation, the actuary certifies the employers’ contribution rates to maintain the viability of the Fund.

 

Fund Management

 

The Committee retains overall responsibility for the Fund, with power to appoint one or more fund managers to manage and invest fund monies on its behalf. In appointing fund managers, the Committee retains statutory responsibility for the management of the Fund and that responsibility cannot be delegated. 

 

The Committee has a statutory duty:-

 

·         To take account of the amount to be managed by each manager and be satisfied, having taken advice, that it is not excessive.

·         To have regard to the suitability of investments.

·         To monitor the performance of the managers and from time to time review their appointment.

·         To take proper advice, obtained at regular intervals.

 

The Committee maintains overall control of the Fund by:

 

·         Agreeing the overall investment objectives with the fund managers taking into account actuarial expectations and investments powers.

·         Setting targets for asset allocation.

·         Monitoring investment performance.

·         Monitoring investment transactions.

 

The Committee has compiled a Statement of Investment Principles (SIP) as required by the Local Government Pension Scheme (Management and Investment of Funds) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2000.  Copies of the SIP are available on request or can be downloaded from the NILGOSC website at www.nilgosc.org.uk.

 

During 2008/09, the Committee expanded its specialist manager structure with the appointment of four new unconstrained managers.  Wellington and Baillie Gifford were each appointed to manage a global unconstrained equities mandate, while BlackRock and Jupiter were selected to manage UK unconstrained equity mandates.  The two global unconstrained mandates were funded in July 2008, with the UK unconstrained equity portfolios funded in early November 2008.  The allocation of the fund between asset classes is determined by the Committee at its annual strategy meeting, normally held in June each year.  The Committee’s passive manager is responsible for maintaining the asset allocation within the agreed ranges.

 

As 31 March 2009, the Committee had the following fund managers in place to manage its equity and fixed interest portfolio:

 

UK Equities              Baillie Gifford

 

UK Unconstrained      BlackRock Investment Management

Equities                   Jupiter Investment Management

         

Global Equities          Wellington Management

 

Global Unconstrained Baillie Gifford

Equities                   Wellington management

 

Bonds                     Aberdeen Asset Management

 

Passive Fund            Legal & General

 

Property                 LaSalle Investment Management

 

In January 2009, the Committee terminated its mandate with it global equities manager Alliance Bernstein following a period of significant underperformance.  While the decision to terminate a mandate would not normally be made on the basis of poor performance alone, a formal retention review by the Committee’s Investment Advisor concluded that in light of the severe underperformance in the second half of 2008, it was hard to justify the continuation of the Alliance Bernstein mandate.  The portfolio was transferred to Legal and General, who are managing the funds on a passive basis in the interim. 

 

At its annual asset allocation meeting in June 2008, the committee agreed to maintain its existing allocation in equities but made changes to its cash and fixed income holdings.  The committee decided to allocate 10% of the total fund (excluding property) to corporate bonds by way of a reduction in fixed interest gilts and cash holdings.  In addition, the fixed allocation to property was increased by £50m from £250m to £300m. The change in the asset allocation was effective from 1 December 2008.

 

 

 

Investment Objectives

 

The majority of the Fund’s liabilities are linked to inflation and salary growth. The overall objective of the Committee is therefore to invest the majority of the assets in investments which are expected to exceed price inflation and general salary growth over long periods.

 

Each element of the Fund portfolio has its own specific performance measure however, as an overall target; the Committee expects the fund return over a 5 year rolling period to outperform the rate of increase in the Retail Price Index (RPI) by 5%. The Committee monitors the investment performance of its investment managers by availing of HSBC’s performance measurement and reporting facility.  Each manager is remunerated on a fee basis, dependent on the market value of the portfolio.

 

The managers have each been given a performance target and asset allocation ranges compiled by the Committee, using indices applicable to the asset type and geographic market.

 

 

 

 

Asset Class

Weight

Target/Benchmark Indices

UK Equities Specialist

37.8%

FTSE All Share Index + 2%
FTSE All Share Index + 4%

FTSE World UK + 2%

MSCI World Developed UK + 3%

FTSE All Share Index

Overseas Equities

44.4%

FTSE All World Developed Index (ex UK) + 2%

FTSE All World Index (ex UK) + 3%

FTSE All World Index + 3%

MSCI World developed Index (ex UK) + 3%

FTSE All World North America Index

FTSE All World Developed Europe ex UK

FTSE All World Japan

FTSE All World Developed Asia Pacific ex Japan

S&P/IFC Investable Composite

Bond Specialist

14.7%

 

 

10.0%

Merrill Lynch Sterling Non – Gilts (AAA-A) + 0.75%

iBoxx £ non-Gilt ex BBB

 

4.7%

FTSE Over 5 Year Index Linked Gilts + 0.75%

Cash

3.1%

LIBID = 0.20%

Total excluding Property

100%

 

Property

£300m

IPD Long Term Funds £100-500m Index + 1%

 

 

The standard target and benchmark for each asset class of the fund as at 31 March 2009 is as above.

 

Market Report

 

The year to 31 March 2009 was when the impact of the global financial crisis, which began nine months earlier in the summer of 2008, spread to the real economy.  Corporate profits fell, unemployment increased, and national government found their finances rapidly deteriorating.  All risk bearing assets such as equities, corporate bonds and property continued falling in value.  Capital was withdrawn from the investment markets.  This was for many reasons.  Some investors became more risk averse and sold out of the risky assets and purchased assets perceived to be such, such as government bonds.  Other investors, especially financial intermediaries such as hedge funds and property fund managers, faced demands from their won investors for cash.  This could only be raised by selling assets at any price.  Some investors took the view that with the economy going into a downturn the prospects for good returns on their investments had fallen, and so decided to exit the market or at least reduce their exposure.   For full commentary please see Annual Report.

 

The graph below shows the indexed returns on the main sectors for the year to 31 March 2009.

 

 

 

Fund Value

 

The value of the Fund at the 31 March 2009 was £2,474m (2007/08 £3,115m), a decrease of £641m (20.6%) on the previous year.

 

Market values can fluctuate widely over short periods of time, reflecting short-term changes in investment conditions. In contrast, the triennial valuation of the fund is concerned with the long-term and uses actuarial assumptions.

 

 


 

Investment Performance

 

Over the year to 31 March 2009, the fund achieved an overall return on the total assets of -21.52%. In comparison, the fund benchmark including property, as set by the Committee, was -20.11%. This resulted in a negative relative return of 1.41%.

 

The Retail Price Index and National Average Earnings decreased by 0.38% and 1.89% respectively during 2008/09.

 

The performance of the individual managers is monitored against their corresponding benchmark on a quarterly basis. The performance returns for each fund manager for the end year ended 31 March 2009 are as follows:-

 

 

Target Return

%

Fund

Return

%

Relative Return

%

Baillie Gifford

UK Equity

Unconstrained*

 

-27.33

-15.74

 

-27.16

-20.67

 

0.17

-4.93

Wellington

Global Equity

Unconstrained*

 

-17.57

-17.64

 

-22.76

-23.92

 

-5.18

-6.28

BlackRock*

 

Jupiter*

-5.79

 

-7.03

1.26

 

-3.59

7.05

 

3.44

AllianceBernstein**

-18.38

-30.73

-12.35

Aberdeen

-1.35

0.95

2.30

Legal & General

-20.42

-20.73

-0.32

LaSalle

-25.20

-25.67

-0.47

 

‘* Performance since inception to 31 March 2009

‘** Mandate terminated January 2009

 

Only the Committee’s UK Equity manager and bond manager both outperformed their respective targets during the year ended 31 March 2009.  Both unconstrained UK equity managers, BlackRock and Jupiter, outperformed their targets for the five months since inception, in November 2008, to 31 March 2009.

 

Wellington, the Committee’s global equity manager, failed to meet its performance objective for the year ended 31 March 2009.  The Committee has in place a robust quarterly monitoring process which aims to look behind returns to see the underlying cause of any underperformance.  Following an informal review in quarter 3, it was determined that there had been no significant change to the underlying investment process which would lead to concerns over Wellington’s ability to deliver expected returns over the longer term.  The committee was very concerned by the ongoing poor performance of its second global equities manager, Alliance Bernstein, who had underperformed its target since appointment in June 2006.  Following substantial underperformance during the first six months of the year, the committee undertook a retention review in December 2008 and the Alliance Bernstein mandate was formally terminated on 26 January 2009.  The underperformance of both global unconstrained managers since inception in August 2008 has been disappointing however it is important to acknowledge that these portfolios are constrained in nature and, in order to deliver higher outperformance, are expected to deviate from the index to a greater extent than constrained managers.  Given the very short timeframe since inception, the Committee is not unduly concerned with returns to date.  The Committee was also satisfied with the performance of its passive manager, Legal and General, who continued its strong track record of outperformance against the various indices throughout the year, while maintaining the Scheme’s overall asset distribution in line with the agreed asset allocation, within pre-determined control ranges. 

 

The property manager, LaSalle, underperformed its benchmark for the year as a result of indirect holdings in the Local Authorities Mutual Investment Trust.  The manager’s investment in direct property holdings on the other hand outperformed the annual benchmark by 5.55%.

 

The Committee’s objective remains to achieve the maximum return on fund investments in the long term, having due regard to the liabilities of the fund and an acceptable level of investment risk. Accordingly, undue attention should not be given to the results for a single year in isolation. The comparable statistics for the three and five year periods to 31 March 2009 on an annualised basis are:

 

 

Three Years

% p.a.

Five Years

% p.a.

Return of Fund

-6.65

2.37

Increase in RPI (RPI + 5%)

7.71

7.74

Composite Benchmark

-5.46

3.75

Increase in National Average Earnings (NAE + 5%)

7.68

8.35

 

 




 

 

Major Investments

 

Top 10 Equity Holdings at 31 March 2009

 

Company

Total Investment

£’000’s

% of Total Equity Portfolio

BG Group

41,270

4.67

British American Tobacco

28,921

3.27

Vodafone

BHP Hilton

Glaxosmithkline

Royal Dutch Shell

26,982

23,665

19,254

19,159

3.05

2.68

2.18

2.17

HSBC Holdings

15,227

1.72

Cairn Energy

12,859

1.46

Astrazeneca

11,576

1.31

Tesco

11,754

1.33